Kali (_thirty2flavors) wrote,
Kali
_thirty2flavors

in which i read HDM ten years after everyone else

SO I recently read His Dark Materials for the first time and... people keep asking me about it in different threads, so here is a conglomerate post that borrows a lot from the TL;DR comment I left noblealice.


First the unsrs lulz:


  • Specters are totally Dementors
  • LOL POLAR BEAR FIGHT
  • Omg, the witches and their "humans WITHER and DIE" angst made me crack up as well
  • Also, zeppelins: mandatory in all your parallel-world needs
  • Will's dad dying at such a climatic moment was just funny, I'm sorry. I'm glad they got to chill in the land of the dead though.
  • I found the start of Golden Compass REALLY slow, ngl. It wasn't until Lyra wound up at Bolvangar that shit started to get real and I started to get interested. I liked Subtle Knife more, and Amber Spyglass most.
  • But the battle in Amber Spyglass was not as epic as I was pulling for, it just kind of ended...
  • omg the sassy gay angels though, LOL A+
  • Lee Scoresby = Yukon Cornelius
  • Metatron is like a Transformer name wtf


Now more tl;dr. I realize I am not really the target audience for this book, and I think that affected how I read things. So possibly some of these things aren't really Pullman's fault, because he's writing for thirteen-year-olds and not 20-somethings working on their English degrees. I suspect bbKali would've loved these books, if she'd read them.

I liked it. The Atheist Agenda was... heavy-handed, but as I understand it these books are basically neener-ing at the Narnia books, so I guess heavy-handedness is appropriate. Plus I am an atheist, so it was a message I could get behind. However, I could easily see how this would be the kind of novel series I would not recommend to particularly religious -- well, particularly Christian -- friends. And I can see why that "BOYCOTT GOLDEN COMPASS RAR" Facebook group popped up when the movie did, lol. He doesn't pull any punches.

I liked the story/the message more than I liked the... IDK, the books? Or -- I mean, with things like Harry Potter and Doctor Who, I love the characters so much that loving the world sort of stems from that, whereas with HDM I found that the characters were okay, but I was never emotionally invested, it was just curiosity borne out of the storyline itself. Like, I found the dialogue really stilted, and I thought they all talked like... well, storybook characters, which created a certain atmosphere but prevented me from seeing the characters as real people, so their motivations/etc were more like bits of the plot than bits of characterization, if that makes any sense. I might not be explaining it very well. I was just talking about this more with bazcat89, and I was saying that... you know when you get really into a book series to the degree where you are so immersed you forget you're reading a story? I couldn't do that with these books; I was always very conscious of the fact that I was reading something with an agenda and so I was always thinking about what he was Doing Thar. I'm not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing, but there it is.

But like, when Mrs Coulter turned out to actually love Lyra, it wasn't a big emotional revelation for me, it was more like an explanation for X/Y/Z. Which, I mean, characterization should influence plot too, but... I dunno, I guess I just wasn't that dazzled by most of his characters.

A big exception to this is Lyra, who I thought was fabulous. Her tenacity and the fact that her gift/strength/whatever was lying and storytelling is a big break from the norm, and I know that's largely what Pullman was going for, and I think he did it well. I read one of the Sally Lockhart books before I read HDM, and I think I'm partially of two minds -- on one hand I really do appreciate him writing heroines whose strengths are stereotypically "male" things, and who aren't wilting violets. On the other hand, I worry that maybe he skirts too close to the assumption that a strong female character is one who acts like a man (according to gender roles, anyway). There's nothing wrong with that on its own, but I grow wary of it because I worry about the take-away message being "to be strong you have to be like a (stereotypical) man", not the message being that there is strength in women as it is. But that's sort of me bringing baggage into the books, I think, based on things in fandom/in other media, so I guess that might not be a fair criticism of Pullman's work in particular. And I DO like Lyra a lot, and Sally. But I would be interested to see him write a strong female character who is "girly". I'm reading the Sally Lockhart books now -- just started the second one -- so it's also possible he will address this at some point, but he hasn't really yet. No spoilers plz~

I though the series picked up speed as it went on, I think Amber Spyglass was my favourite of the three. I liked Will too, he and Lyra were probably the only characters I felt particularly attached to -- though I also liked Iorek because LOL POLAR BEAR and the mulefa because LOL SPACE ELEPHANTS.

The writing, as in the actual technical prose, I thought was more mature than most things I see in YA, but then I haven't read much YA in a long time. Sometimes he had turns of phrase/sentences that I thought were pretty brilliant. I've forgotten most of them now, but the passage about "being in love was like China -- probably it was very nice, and other people would go there, but I never would" or whatever to be really clever. On a technical level I also think he constructed his themes and his metaphors and his storylines quite well. They're well-written and worth a read (though obviously contentious) but I think perhaps I was too old when I read them to really latch onto them the way other people have, since they weren't part of my childhood.

Finally: the 12-year-olds-have-sex passage squicked me out big time. I know why it was there, but omg they're so little D:
Tags: books: best weapons in the world
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 58 comments