Tallian (_tallian_) wrote,
Tallian
_tallian_

  • Location:
  • Mood:
  • Music:

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - my thoughts

I’ll put most of it (including all spoilers) behind a cut, for politeness’ sake.


There were a few things that either I missed in the previous books or forgot about, or JKR didn’t explain fully enough for me. Like, when did Dudley get studly? The last I remember, he was a plump bully weeping after the encounter with a dementor.

I’m also confused about the whole Fidelius charm, now. I thought once the original Secret Keeper was dead, the charm dissipated. So when Dumbledore died, the secret instead passed on to the twenty-or-so people whom he’d told? I realize it was an important plot point for 12 Grimmald Place be available, but I’m still not clear on the continuity.

And when did Remus become one-dimensional? I have no problem with the Lupin/Tonks, even though I totally ship Sirius/Lupin. I think they could have been lovely together. But we never got to see it! Suddenly they’re married, Tonks is blissfully unaware of Lupin’s unhappiness, they expect a baby, Lupin freaks out, Lupin’s ok, they both kak in an undescribed battle. I felt – unfulfilled, there.

However, I loved Dobby saving Harry et al. Kreatcher saving the day with an army of house-elves. George feeling “saintly” when he woke up with a hole in his head. The big reveal at the end with the Pensieve. Everyone’s flaws were revealed, and made use of.

I’ve noticed that a lot of people love Snape as a character, but not as a person. I really agree with this. I felt for him as we learned about his childhood and his love for Lily (which I wholeheartedly intend to ship), and his death scene was great. I’m still not clear on what (other than blood) was gushing from his mouth. I was probably reading too fast, but I even went back to re-read that section.


On the whole, I liked it a lot, and I’ll check out the next book she puts out. I’m interested to see if that’s all she has in her. Hopefully not; I really like her world-building.
Tags: hpdh, review
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments