Publisher: Five Star, 2007
Genre: Fantasy
Sub-genre: Swords and sorcery
Read the full (spoiler-free) review here!Alright, let's be honest. This cover has all the clichéd aspects of fantasy in one overly dark picture. Creepy-looking tyrant dude? Check. Swords and a rider on horseback? Check. Medieval-style clothing? Check. Even shiny magical bits glittering in the background! Basically, this cover tells me "there is nothing new to see here. Move along."
For me, reading this book was an excellent example of why it's so important to "show" instead of "tell." The whole book is written with a great distance from the characters, and more often than not events feel like they're being told as part of a story, rather than playing out for the reader to experience. As a result, I just couldn't find it in myself to care about any of the characters or what was happening. Sometimes the character motivations or logic didn't seem to make any sense, although they might have had we been more in their heads.
There were a few occasions I felt like I'd missed entire scenes, too, and at least twice went back to make sure I hadn't missed something. In one scene, Aeolia asks the guy she's mad about if they can get married, and then tells him not to reply so she won't have to hear him refuse. Next we see them, they're already married. I don't necessarily need a big elaborate wedding scene, but it'd be nice to hear something more definite than "No, don't talk... because I couldn't bear it if you turned me down. Here, what's this? I see you want to speak. I will kiss you lest you refuse me."
The dialogue was stilted, the characters seemed to move through as dictated by plot instead of making their own rational decisions, and in general the book just couldn't keep my attention. The thing took me far too long to finish. I will admit to liking the magic system presented here, with each culture having its own particular talent, and the scenes near the beginning where Aeolia was forced to serve her ogre master had some potential. Actually, I kind of wish this had been the story of Aeolia the slavegirl, rather than Aeolia the girl who escaped slavery to randomly plod through until she makes her way to King Sinther the tyrant.
Note to self: on occasion, it's ok to judge a book by its cover. Sometimes it's just truth in advertising.