I just came across something that confuses me quite a bit - maybe someone can help explain it to me.
I just watched an ad that someone apparently allowed to be on TV about how same-sex marriage is a "gathering storm" (YouTube it) and how it is a threat and imposes on the rights of Christians and concerned parents. I went to the website of the organization, just to see how deep the crazy went, and again found more statements that used the phrase "IMPOSING same-sex marriage".
The logic of this phrasing confuses me. What it seems like they're trying to say is that allowing gays to marry infringes on the rights of people who don't like same-sex marriage. But to me, that doesn't make any sense. Here's why:
I really fail to see how same-sex marriages impose on anyone. The commercial was talking about how some guy's company wasn't allowed to discriminate against gays and some mom had to let her kids be taught about how homosexuality isn't horrible and evil. HORROR. I bet it's really hard for KKK members to watch their kids go to public school with black kids, too, or to live in this country now that there's a black president. I bet there's some man out there who really hates that I'm typing on a computer in my college dorm right now instead of making him a sandwich and bearing his children. But does anyone (rational) feel sorry for these people, or concerned that their rights are being "imposed upon"? Because I sure don't.
From a legal standpoint, though, the imposing thing really doesn't make ANY sense. You can't impose on a right that doesn't exist. The right to discriminate? Not a right. It's not in the Constitution. I don't know who told people that they had the right to deny people jobs based on personal opinion about gender, race, or sexuality, but from my (admittedly limited) understanding of the American legal system this has never been anyone's right - in fact it seems to me that it's pretty much the opposite of civil rights. Did I...miss something? Any poli-sci students out there are free to correct me.
And as for kids being taught in school that it's okay to be gay - isn't this really the same argument as the whole teaching evolution in schools thing? If you're the kind of parent who doesn't want your children being exposed to anything that you don't agree with or believe in, then take them out of public school and teach them yourself. Because that's the only way they're never going to hear anything that you don't want them to hear. Or, better yet, take the time you spend making hateful offensive TV commercials and TALK TO YOUR CHILDREN. If you want your kids to oppose gay marriage, then you sit with them at home and tell them why you think it's wrong and that the bad liberal hippie teacher is trying to fill their brain with propaganda. No one's stopping you. Why? Because that really WOULD be imposing on your rights.
This seems like mostly a public vs. private debate to me. Like I said above, it's the difference between stopping something being taught to a large group of children in a public school and preventing a parent from teaching their own child something in their own home. No one is trying to take away the latter, only the former, because public rights are a matter of civic concern and private rights are - well, private. As I see them, private things are things that only affect one person or a small group of people (like that person and their partner, or their family and friends). What I don't understand is how marriage isn't private. If I went outside right now and married the first man I saw, would it affect any of you reading this? I'm sure my friends and family would be confused and upset that I'd made such a rash decision, but would it, say, "impose" on their rights? I can't see how.
The more I think about this, the less I can see the logic in it. But I'm still willing to wonder if I'm wrong. So some general questions for anyone reading this:
Male friends: Do you feel like it imposes on your rights when I vote? Go to class? Refuse to marry you? If I were to wear a short skirt and walk across the street, would my personal choice of clothing affect the public enough that any man who sees me has the right to rape me (taking away my personal right to choose who I have sex with)?
Homosexual friends: Does heterosexual marriage impose on YOUR rights? If I marry a man, will this cause a "gathering storm" to blow in and ruin your lives? If I marry a woman, will it consequently make everything in your life wonderful and perfect? And, most importantly, does this wedding dress make me look fat?
Religious friends: Does having freedom of religion mean that you're free from having anyone ever question, challenge, or pass laws that contradict your religious beliefs? Does it mean your children should never be taught about anything that doesn't comply with them? Could it be possible that freedom of religion means your children could have the opportunity to choose their own religious beliefs, even if they're different than yours? And just for the Christians: If homosexuality is a sin, and God punishes sinners in the afterlife, and you're 100% sure that God and hell exist, then does it matter if gays get married here on Earth? Won't they be punished for their sins by God later anyway? Couldn't you just look the other way and let Him take care of it?
I'm interested to see if anyone has answers for these questions. Your input is greatly appreciated - maybe someone can help me understand how people can actually rationalize this whole "imposing gay marriage" thing. It's really hurting my brain (and soul) at the moment. Thanks in advance!