Palin was surprisingly likable. But she pushed trademarked issues, avoided questions completely, didn't give many clear answers, and the answers she did give sounded like they were rehearsed to death. As someone in a commentary remarked, "As a teacher, Gov. Palin's answers reminded me of one of the problems with No Child Left Behind. Some teachers will teach the answers to the test. It seems as though this was a test for her. She memorized answers, but it was for the wrong version of the standardized test. That did not seem to stop her from reciting the answers she memorized." She didn't burst into flames, but she REALLY didn't impress me. And I find her small town attitude positively grating. I grew up in Tower, MN. The population now is 479. It wasn't that many in 1979. I am a small town gal from the north. I still want to smack her. Do you think that it's going to go well when she rolls her eyes and gives them some anecdote from Alaska when she's meeting leaders of other countries? Also, could you say the word "also" one more time for me, Gov. Palin? (For those of you interested, she said ALSO 48 times.) And fact checkers are showing that she greatly exaggerated more times than Biden did.
Biden, I thought was good, though. I didn't necessarily agree with him on all of the things he said, but I felt that he was more informative and presented well. He did well with the facts. I didn't doubt his sincerity as much as I did Palin's, which seemed contrived. I think he'd make a fantastic president, truthfully. He was intelligent, kind and firm. He handled Palin well. He didn't even say anything when Palin called the commander of U.S. troops in Afghanistan as McClellan (instead of McKiernan) twice. Even if his teeth were blindingly white, I still really liked him. Not that it was a question before, but there is certainly no question now as to where my vote is.
ETA: I forgot to mention the health care issue. I thought Palin was deceiving (as many of her statements were, if you look them up). I was happy to hear Biden explain that, while you will be getting $5000, the average health care plan is going to cost $12000, thus leaving way more people uninsured. Palin made Obama's plan sound like universal health care, which it isn't. It's making sure that all children are covered and leaving adults the right to choose their plan. And I'm slightly annoyed that so many Republicans I've run into criticized the "Change" mantra of the Obama campaign, and now they are trying to market it for themselves!