07 April 2012 @ 10:03 pm
ron swanson.gif  
I guess Hugo nominations are out?

For the people on my flist who don't know, the Hugos are some supposedly-prestigious-but-only-if-you're-a-scifi-nerd-on-the-internet-I-think award for scifi stuff. As someone who generally gives no shits about awards, the Hugos have an unprecedented capacity to make me butthurt. It's partly the Ron Swanson thing, and partly the fact that fandom like to wave them around as incontestable proof of something's quality. As a not-unrelated point, the Hugo awards love Steven Moffat.

So anyway, someone told me earlier that this year's crop for the "short drama presentation" category included "The Doctor's Wife" (fine), "The Girl Who Waited" (yes plz!)... and "A Good Man Goes To War". I kind of grumbled about how at least it's not "Let's Kill Hitler" or "The Wedding of River Song".



IT IS "REMEDIAL CHAOS THEORY", AKA MY FAVOURITE COMMUNITY EPISODE POSSIBLY EVER.



What's great about this episode is that it takes a sci-fi concept and applies it flawlessly in a show that is not sci-fi, and uses that sci-fi concept to illustrate things about the characters and their relationships, rather than just needlessly flailing around about how clever it is. For a 22-minute sitcom episode, it is ludicrously complex, but all seven of the timelines are easy to follow and well-integrated.

In conclusion, if "Remedial Chaos Theory" loses to "A Morally Gray Man Saunters Vaguely in the Direction of a Non-Violent Conflict and Then Loses His BFF's Baby Though No One Cares", I will burn Utica to the ground.
 
 
( Read 31 commentsLeave a comment )
phoenixrising06: dw- rosetardistenphoenixrising06 on April 8th, 2012 05:04 am (UTC)
Sorry for the interruption, but you have no idea how happy this makes me. Seriously, I was all prepared for them to fall head over heels for GitF (especially since that one guy has started ragging on Rose all the time) and I was prepared to be all Ron Swanson "I HATE EVERYTHING" after reading it. Especially since DWM seems to be completely up Moffat's rear these days.
Kali_thirty2flavors on April 8th, 2012 05:07 am (UTC)
Q: I know nothing about DWM or what panel this is, but is this a feature where people just review old episodes? Are there any women on this "panel"?
phoenixrising06: dw- donna/purplephoenixrising06 on April 8th, 2012 05:13 am (UTC)
From what I understand, it's a group of four (two men, two women) who gather to watch the show and review it every month. They started with Classic Who, working their way up month to month. And while they claim to be completely unspoiled for NuWho, I'm not certain I entirely believe this. I mean, I'm some random American girl who wanted nothing to do with the show until last year and I still managed to get spoiled for major plot points while it was on. I'm not sure how they've managed to avoid it if they did. Sorcery?
Kali: dw :: jenny :: awful lot of running_thirty2flavors on April 8th, 2012 05:25 am (UTC)
Haha I'm skeptical of the spoilerfree claim too. Oh well.

I'm glad it's 2 and 2 though, I was just complaining earlier about the boys-club aspect of sci-fi fandom/DW's powers that be, so I was all ready to be morally outraged at a panel of dudes telling me how to feel about New Who eps.