02 February 2010 @ 09:16 pm
fic: making do  
Title: Making Do
Characters/Pairings: Donna/Shaun
Rating: PG
Genre: A bit of fluff, a bit of angst.
Spoilers?: Through End of Time: Part 2
Length: ~2k
Excerpt: “You know when you’re trying to think of a word and it’s on the tip of your tongue and you know it’s there but you just can’t think of it? It’s like that. All the time.” She laughs once and looks down at her lap. “You must think I’m mental.”
Summary: Life goes on for Donna Noble.


In the first floor of the building Donna Noble works in, there’s a dodgy little café.

She finds it on her first day, during that awkward lunch-hour she’s got no one to spend with. It’s fantastically boring work she’s doing, plugging data into computer programs, and she’s certain she’ll need a good, strong dose of caffeine if she’s going to stay awake.

Instead she winds up staring at the man behind the counter incredulously.

“What do you mean, you don’t have tea?” she demands, her eyes narrowing suspiciously.

“Ran out, like I said,” he says. “Ridiculous, I know.”

“How do you run out of tea? It’s a café!”

“Sorry,” he says, and though he sounds apologetic he looks somewhat amused. “Can I get you a coffee instead?”

“I don’t drink coffee anymore,” Donna snaps, feeling severely put out as she stares up at the menu.

“‘Anymore’?” he asks. “Why not?” There’s a hint of genuine interest that stops Donna from telling him to mind his own business. Sometimes Donna feels like it’s been much too long since someone talked to her with genuine interest.

She looks at him, her eyes drifting to his nametag. Shaun, it says. “I can’t remember,” she admits, suddenly feeling daft.

“You’ve just not had the right cup,” Shaun says decisively, pointing at her. “I’ll make you one. Best coffee you’ll ever have.” He winks. “I promise.”

Donna looks at him with one eyebrow raised, but his stare is so earnest that finally she sighs. “Fine,” she concedes, and she’s just about to pull her purse out of her handbag when it dawns on her he might be flirting.

Feels like a long time since that’s happened, too.

She cranes her neck just a bit to sneak a peak over the counter when he turns to make the coffee, and then feigns interest in her handbag when he turns around. He holds the cup out to her and smiles.

“There you go,” Shaun says, and then lowers his voice to a whisper. “On the house.”

Definitely flirting, Donna thinks, and she can’t help but grin as she heads back to the office.

It’s a bloody good cup of coffee, too.

--

The dodgy little café on the first floor becomes something of a lunch-hour habit for Donna, and as he works every day, so does the flirting with Shaun. He never runs out of tea again but she orders coffee anyway. They share bits and pieces of each other in the brief exchanges over the cash register. Donna files each one away and mulls over it later while she drinks her coffee and does her mindless work. He lives with a roommate, a bloke named Greg. He’s got two brothers and a sister and all their names begin with ‘S’. He’s always wanted to be a chef but never been able to afford the classes.

It’s not such a bad tradition, as a mid-day pick-me-up, and within two weeks it’s Donna’s favourite part of the nine-to-five.

By four weeks, it’s her favourite part of the day, period.

--

One Tuesday she heads down to find a bored-looking young girl standing behind the counter.

“Traded shifts,” the girl explains, not quite bothering to make eye-contact as she says it. “He’s working my Saturday.” She shrugs. “It’s his birthday today.”

It may be a bit of an overreaction for someone she’s only flirted with, but Donna spends the rest of the day deciding what to get him.

--

She settles on a cookbook and one of those big white chef hats. She deliberates over a card for much too long and finally decides not to get one, signing the little tag on the gift bag instead. She waits around until he’s on break to give it to him, and the second she hands the bag over she’s convinced she’s just made a gigantic fool of herself. He probably gives free coffees to every woman who comes into the shop, all of whom are probably far prettier than she is and none of whom are daft enough to buy him bloody birthday gifts.

But his face lights up when he opens it, and he laughs and beams at her so sincerely she feels a little less daft.

And then he says, “Oh, Donna, you’re brilliant,” and she snogs him right then and there.

He tells her later that was the best part of the gift.

--

He cooks for her on their first date, and Donna’s too embarrassed to ask if it’s because he can’t afford to take her out. There was a time, Donna thinks, with no small amount of shame, that might have put her off, but now it hardly seems to matter, and it’s not like she’s got money to spare, either, not with her temping job ending soon. And anyway she’s anxious to see if his cooking lives up to his coffee.

His roommate Greg is just on his way out the door when she arrives, but he stops to say hello and assures her he’s heard great things. Shaun’s flat is small and cramped, but it’s nice, she thinks, in a homey sort of way, and the sofa in the living room is perfect for watching television.

He puts out a bottle of wine on the table and very nearly burns the dinner because, he says, he’s nervous. Donna feels giddy before she’s even had a sip of the Syrah and helps herself to a big piece of pie even though she hates pears. He laughs at her jokes and doesn’t mind when she’s loud, and somehow—this is the miracle, Donna thinks—he makes her feel important.

--

“Can I ask you something?” he asks her one night, three months later, while they sit on his sofa and watch the credits for Back to the Future roll across the screen. It’s a weird movie, Donna thinks. She’s certain she liked it more the last time she watched it. Now it just seems wrong.

“Sure,” she says absently, her mind still stuck on flux capacitors.

“You seem quite sad sometimes,” Shaun says, jolting Donna back to reality. His voice is soft and concerned, like he’s worried he’ll frighten her off. “Like… something’s wrong. What is it? Is it your dad?”

Donna doesn’t look at him. She stares at the screen, suddenly feeling exposed. “No,” she says, “no, it’s…” She swallows, and her throat is suddenly thick. “I don’t know what it is,” she admits. “It’s like… like something’s missing. It’s like I’ve left the stove on, or I’ve left something behind, or…”

She gives her head a shake and looks at him. “You know when you’re trying to think of a word and it’s on the tip of your tongue and you know it’s there but you just can’t think of it? It’s like that. All the time.” She laughs once and looks down at her lap. “You must think I’m mental.”

“Nah.” He puts an arm around her and Donna leans in, resting her head against his shoulder. “I think you’re brilliant.”

--

Donna is having an absolutely shit day when Shaun proposes.

She gets in a fight with her mother over who pays for most of the petrol. Her computer freezes and costs her three hours of effort at work. In the elevator, someone backs into her and Donna spills her coffee all down the front of her suit. She breaks a nail trying to work the fax machine, it rains so hard she gets drenched on her way to her car, and when he calls “come in!” instead of opening the door himself, Donna is ready to scream at him. He’s been working loads lately, picking up shifts and pulling doubles, and when they finally manage a night to see each other, he’s not even interested enough to come to the door.

But when she lets herself in she finds him crouched on one knee, a bouquet in one hand and a tiny velvet box in the other, and she winds up screaming for entirely different reasons.

--

She forgets about the lottery ticket until she takes off her wedding dress.

It’s quite an intricate process, getting in and out of one of those, and Donna doesn’t even notice when it flutters to the floor, all crumpled.

Shaun does, though. He crouches down and picks it up, smoothing it out with his fingers as he wrinkles his forehead.

“A lottery ticket?” He stares at her, perplexed. “Who gave us this?”

Donna Temple-Noble raises her eyebrows and looks at him sternly. “Are you seriously more interested in a lotto ticket than in me taking off this dress?”

Shaun laughs, and the lotto ticket gets placed on the night table.

--

She forgets the lotto ticket until Shaun brings in the paper the next day.

“It was just sitting outside the door,” he says, shrugging as he tosses it on the table. “Guess it’s free.”

Donna finds she’s not particularly interested in the paper on the morning of her honeymoon, but she opens it anyway. “Where’s that lotto ticket?” she asks, flipping through to the proper section.

She double-checks the numbers once, twice, three times once he hands her the ticket.

Then she screams so loud they get a noise complaint, and knocks over her coffee as she leaps up to throw her arms around him.

--

There are a million things they can do now that they couldn’t do before.

Find a nice house. Get a car. Shaun can sign up for cooking classes.

“What do you want to do?” he asks her, almost two weeks after their big win.

The answer comes to her before she even stops to think about it.

“Travel,” she says.

So they do.

--

One night in Hawaii, Donna wakes up feeling like she’s on fire.

Her eyes snap open and she sits up in bed, her heart thumping in her chest while her head pounds. She draws in a gasping breath and blinks blearily around the room, trying desperately to get her bearings straight. She feels warm all over, uncomfortably so, and her skin feels like it’s burning. It’s a second before she realizes her cheeks are wet, and another second before she realizes she’s crying.

What the hell had she been dreaming about?

The sheets rustle as Shaun sits up beside her. “Donna?” His voice croaks with sleep. “Are you all right?”

“I’m…” Donna starts, but trails off when she can’t find the words. She shakes her head and draws in a stuttering breath.

“Donna?” Shaun puts his arm around her shoulders, his worry clear in his voice. “What’s wrong?”

In between short, hiccupping breaths, Donna stammers, “I don’t know.”

There’s a tempest of emotions swirling in her that she can’t even begin to explain. She’s scared, but she doesn’t know what of. There’s a crushing, aching loneliness in the pit of her stomach that feels like it belongs to someone else. She’s furious, like fate has stripped her bare of everything but the knowledge that life is bitterly unfair.

And she’s sad—desperately sad—like she’s lost someone she loves.

Shaun pulls her closer and Donna twists towards him, muffling a sob by burying her face in his chest. She weeps into his shirt, wracked by a grief she can’t understand.

--

She wakes up the next morning to the smell of bacon.

By the time she opens her eyes light is streaming in through the window and Shaun’s side of the bed is empty, but she takes one big breath and smiles into her pillow. Better than room service, he is. She doesn’t even have to tip.

She ties the sash of her robe as she makes her way into the kitchenette. She creeps up behind him and peeks over his shoulder.

“Bacon and crêpes?” She grins. “I bloody love you.”

Shaun nods. “I should hope so.”

She grabs the milk from the fridge and a glass from the counter and sits down at the table, perfectly content. It’s not until Shaun sets a plate in front of her and asks, “How are you feeling?” that she remembers that she remembers the previous night.

She blinks down at her bacon, surprised and a little embarrassed. “Fine,” she says, reflexively at first, before she repeats it with more conviction. “I’m… fine.”

Shaun sits down across from her, a look of concentrated concern on his face. “What was it?” he asks gently. “You can tell me.”

“I don’t know,” she answers flatly. She shrugs stabs a piece of bacon with her fork. “Honestly. Not a clue.” She pops the bacon in her mouth. “Sorry.”

He still looks worried, but he nods nevertheless. “It’s all right.” He frowns. “Do you feel any better this morning?”

Donna doesn’t answer at first. She sets her fork down and looks out the glass door that leads to the balcony, through which she can just see the deep turquoise of the ocean. She thinks about the previous night, bawling inexplicably. It was the hardest she’d cried since her father died, and she doesn’t even know why.

But now she’s sitting at the table of a hotel suite in Hawaii, eating bacon and crêpes with her husband and looking at the ocean. She’s got more money than she ever dreamed of. In three days, they’re on a flight to Tokyo. She’s seen more of the world in the last four months than she’d ever imagined, and for some reason the man sitting across the table looks at her like she’s the most important woman in the world. It's not exactly making do, is it?

“Yeah,” she says, and she can feel herself letting go of something as she does. “Yeah.” She smiles. “Much better.”

Shaun smiles back at her. “Good.”

Donna Temple-Noble cuts a piece of crêpe and takes a bite, then wrinkles her nose. “Did you put pears in this?”
 
 
Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>
( 59 comments — Leave a comment )
Lady Moon-Loona-cyjennytork on February 3rd, 2010 02:36 am (UTC)
.........why do I get the sneaking feeling that Ten's "I don't want to go" sent part of him into Donna? Without killing her this time?And that he still lives in her?
Kali: dw :: doctordonna :: nothing special_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 03:01 am (UTC)
Aww! I didn't have anything quite so literal in mind, but I guess you could read it like that if you want. In my mind she was sort of getting ...some kind of residual Time Lord SOS, lol.

Thanks for reading!
amelia: incessant blatherer: tardiselevenmeelsie_love78 on February 3rd, 2010 02:40 am (UTC)
This is brilliant, utterly.

Your characterisation of Donna is perfect, and Shaun is exactly how I've imagined him to be. I love the easy, simple way their relationship develops; it rings very true.

I can't possibly gush any more over this, or I'll never shut up - it's the piece I've been wanting and hoping to write since watching EoT, but you've pulled it off far better than I ever could have. Bravo!

I'd love to rec this around a little, if you don't mind?
Kali: dw :: donna :: plucky young girl_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 03:06 am (UTC)
Aw, thank you! I know Donna's ending isn't the one a lot of people would have chosen for her, myself included, but I do like to think she'll be happy with Shaun, and writing this certainly helped convince myself of that. He seemed like a good guy in the brief glimpse we got of him, and I firmly subscribe to the notion that all Donna needs is someone to believe in her.

I'm glad you liked it! Go ahead and rec away, if you like. Thanks again!
(no subject) - meelsie_love78 on February 3rd, 2010 03:11 am (UTC) (Expand)
a lanky brunette with a wicked jaw: dw || donna; light in wildernessintrikate88 on February 3rd, 2010 02:49 am (UTC)
Oh, this is so sweet and heartbreaking and in character and perfect.
Kali: dw :: doctordonna :: you were right_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 03:11 am (UTC)
Thank you! I feel bad for Donna, but I'm sure she'll be happy enough.
don't be afraid, don't ever be afraid: [DW] Donna!thinkatory on February 3rd, 2010 03:29 am (UTC)
This rings a thousand times true, I love the way you develop Donna and Shaun, and the proposal scene made me grin stupidly at my screen. Great work.
Kali: dw :: donna :: did she trust you?_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 03:35 am (UTC)
Thank you! Donna and Shaun was sort of interesting to write, because there's so little canon basis, but once I got going it wound up clicking pretty easily. I've possibly even convinced myself to ship it, lol.
Austin: Donnajohnmayergirl23 on February 3rd, 2010 03:44 am (UTC)
UM, YOU GOT THE CHARACTERIZATION ALL WRONG, BECAUSE WITHOUT HER MEMORIES, DONNA IS TOTALLY USELESS AND STUPID AND SUPERFICIAL AND WOULD BE BETTER OFF DEAD. KTHXBYE.

No, but seriously, I'm a fan. I really love your Donna, and this reminded me of that ... other post-JE fic you wrote. I'm too lazy to look for a title, but you know the one I'm talking about. I also really loved Shaun; he's adorable and tells her she's brilliant and makes her coffee that's not slowly poisoning her. :D

Lovely, lovely.
Kali: dw :: donna :: yatta_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 03:50 am (UTC)
:O HDU HDU HDU

Yeah it's similar in tone and style ... and content, since I called the lotto ticket thing like two years early, what what. I became quite fond of my own imagining of Shaun too, but I do think this is the sort of guy Donna would wind up settling down with -- someone really supportive who is just totally (rightfully) dazzled by her, lirl.

Thank you!
(no subject) - johnmayergirl23 on February 3rd, 2010 04:24 am (UTC) (Expand)
(no subject) - _thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 07:51 pm (UTC) (Expand)
Glynnis: Donnaquean_of_swords on February 3rd, 2010 03:55 am (UTC)
This made me smile and it made me cry. Lovely lovely. ^_^
Kali: dw :: donna :: baby it's cold outside_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 04:08 am (UTC)
Aw thank you! Yeah, I wanted it to be mostly happy, but I think it's sort of impossible to write Donna post-JE without there being at least a bit of angst.
erateinierateini on February 3rd, 2010 04:05 am (UTC)
Maybe Donna's ending wasn't a perfect ending but your story helps cement that it was a happy one!
Kali: dw :: donna :: the noblest_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 04:10 am (UTC)
Thank you! Yeah, while it will always be sad Donna can't remember, I do think it was a happy ending overall, and there are worse things than being financially secure and happily married, I think.
quickyfant: crazy!Tenquickyfant on February 3rd, 2010 04:11 am (UTC)
This and "Perchance to a Dream" make me a little bit less angry at the "resolution" Donna had in EoT!!! I loved this! It made me go from a meh feeling in EoT to YAY for Donna and Shaun!

And I am so in denial and emotionally unstable since EoT that this And then he says, “Oh, Donna, you’re brilliant,” and she snogs him right then and there. He tells her later that was the best part of the gift. made start tearing up...
Every brilliant and pear is wonderful! Why wasnt she there to give him a hug at the end!!!! *glares at RTD* Thanks so much for this!
Kali: dw :: doctordonna :: walking in dust_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:36 pm (UTC)
LOL, yeah, writing them both has been quite cathartic for me as well. Donna's ending was maybe not ideal, but I do think she has every capability of being happy /etc in life even without those memories.

Why wasnt she there to give him a hug at the end!!!! *

Aww it would've been nice to have something like that. Poor Ten.

Thanks for reading!
Sarah Catherine: Aliceelirrina on February 3rd, 2010 04:19 am (UTC)
Oh, Ten, you would have to leave Donna with an irrational dislike of pears, wouldn't you? I love this, and I'm happy that Donna and Shaun get to be happy.
Kali: dw :: donna :: plucky young girl_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:41 pm (UTC)
Well, pears are gross. lirl.

I do think they will be, more or less, I thought they were cute in the tiny clips we got of them.

Thank you!
clodia: Irisclodia_risa on February 3rd, 2010 04:23 am (UTC)
Yes.
Kali: dw :: donna :: wanna bet time boy?_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:47 pm (UTC)
Hee. Thanks for reading!
demented & sad, but social: dw: loves them allpapilio_luna on February 3rd, 2010 04:25 am (UTC)
*flails* YAY BRILLIANT! I love how you write Donna, truly.

And did you know there's a community to cross-post you fic that features minor characters such as Shaun?! Didja? Huh? ;)

Edited at 2010-02-03 04:25 am (UTC)
Kali: dw :: donna :: aren't we all?_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:54 pm (UTC)
Why thank you! I really like writing Donna, though I do find a lot of her Catherine Tate-y gestures hard to transcribe and wind up hoping readers can insert them as they see fit, lol.

ORLY? I figured this was too Donna-centric to qualify.
willendinrain: Donna's Winningswillendinrain on February 3rd, 2010 05:25 am (UTC)
As per usual, I flippin' love it! I mean, if I'm going to be completely honest with myself, reading your DW fanfiction was one of the contributing factors in me watching the show in the first place. Then, of course, the awesome carried me through, but still!

Anyways, Donna is my best favorite and I am really thrilled to read about her doing better than okay. Even with seeing the Doctor give her the winning ticket and all, I could never be happy with a Donna who is less than the Donna we know she should be. But, then, I recall that there is contentment in every day life and not just with Time Lords. Thanks for reminding me.
Kali: dw :: doctordonna :: best of friends_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:57 pm (UTC)
If it makes you feel better it's apparently my mission in life to slowly convert everyone to Doctor Who by just... never shutting up about it, so I am glad this was part of the process, lol.

But, then, I recall that there is contentment in every day life and not just with Time Lords.

Yeah. I mean, it would've been great if Donna'd gotten her memories back, and I really thought she would, but... she can still be happy without them. And I don't think not having them makes her lesser as a person -- like we saw in Turn Left, Donna doesn't need the Doctor, she just needs someone to have a little faith in her. Who's to say that can't be Shaun?

Thank you!
Kay: doctor who RUN!ghraphite on February 3rd, 2010 01:56 pm (UTC)
*looks up from work bench* Huh? What? Yes, yes, nice story. Very nice. Now, excuse me while I'm grafting this onto canon.

I truely love this. If I could, I'd marry it.
Kali: dw :: donna :: baby it's cold outside_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 02:58 pm (UTC)
HEE. Well, it's not contradicted by canon, so there's no reason to assume it's not. (lol, this is my typical approach to fanfiction I like.)

Thanks! I think I've said this before, but while I generally find the comics look kind of horrifying, your icon is really cute.
vespertanmer on February 3rd, 2010 04:33 pm (UTC)
I'm sitting here, trying not to cry. Not having much success. I liked this a lot, thank you.
Kali: dw :: donna :: yatta_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 04:47 pm (UTC)
Aw thanks! I'm glad you liked it. It was somewhat therapeutic to write.
Lindsayrowofstars on February 3rd, 2010 07:04 pm (UTC)
I feel like I need a Donna icon just so I can comment on marvelous fic like this. Despite Donna not getting the ending I might have wanted, I can believe she as happy as you've made her and it's wonderful. I love how you characterized Shaun and that he makes her feel like the most important woman in the world. I think that's what we all want, to see that someone else thinks we are that damn awesome. :)

*runs off to find a damn Donna icon*
Kali: dw :: team tardis :: ver. pete's world_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 07:32 pm (UTC)
Yeah. I mean, of course it would have been lovely if Donna got her memories back, but given the constraints... I think she came out of it pretty well. There are worse things than being happily married. And the thing with Donna is that all she really needs is someone who believes in her, so I choose to believe Shaun can fill that roll.

HEE. I have quite a number of Donna icons, it must be said.

Thank you!
Smitty: DW: donnaaeshna_uk on February 3rd, 2010 07:17 pm (UTC)
Oh, this is lovely - a much-needed reminder that Donna did get a happy ending, even if it wasn't the ending that many fans would have chosen for her. She has love, security, her family around her, and I can't help but think that, ultimately, Donna will be far happier with her lot than Rose, who does remember.

Wonderful stuff - thank you! :D
Kali: dw :: cloen/rose :: still got it_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 07:39 pm (UTC)
I think she did, yeah. Maybe not fandom's ideal ending -- and maybe not Donna's ideal ending, for that matter -- but given the constraints of the show itself, I think she came out pretty well. Like you said, she doesn't remember enough to really miss it, and while she may still get sad sometimes like Wilf says, well... who doesn't? She's still in a better place now than she was when she started the series.

I must confess to being among the happy few who believe Rose and her Doctor will be happy, though, lol.

Thanks for reading!
Ing: donna | hee!hysteriagalore on February 3rd, 2010 07:35 pm (UTC)
Oh. Ooooh. I had a smile on my face the entire time reading this. At first it was a smile of glee and then a little bit sad (the Ten regeneration part) and then happy again. I loved it :D

I liked how you weaved in small Ten'ish things in Donna. So good, Kali!
Kali: dw :: donna :: plucky young girl_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 07:42 pm (UTC)
It is certainly the overall happiest thing I have written in a long while! But you know how I work. When fandom is convinced someone will be miserable, I make them happy. And then once fandom accepts that they're probably happy I have them explode a busload of tourists or something.

Thanks! I think she'd retain some things, here and there -- and I guess RTD agrees. I got so excited when she bought Wilf that book without knowing why, lol. It was like he has validated all of my fanfiction.
plutoplutokitty on February 3rd, 2010 08:55 pm (UTC)
This was wonderful. I always felt rather sad about what happened to Donna, but I think you've made me see it otherwise. Thank you so much for this story.
Kali: dw :: doctors :: more fun that way_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 09:13 pm (UTC)
Donna's story is very sad, but I do think she got a happy ending in EOT, even if it wasn't the happy ending most people wanted for her. I think people make the mistake of assuming she can only be brilliant with the Doctor, but Turn Left was some pretty conclusive evidence on the contrary, I think.

Thank you! Glad it helped.
the enemy of fun: DW Donna halononelvis on February 3rd, 2010 10:40 pm (UTC)
You did a beautiful job fleshing out Shaun's character, as well as showing how loving his relationship with Donna is. I really loved this story.
Kali: dw :: teamtardis :: only take the best_thirty2flavors on February 3rd, 2010 11:21 pm (UTC)
Thanks! I like to think Donna must've found someone who recognized her inner Awesome, and in the brief glimpses we got of Shaun he seemed to really care about her.
alternately stone in you and star: donnalunarla225 on February 4th, 2010 04:09 am (UTC)
This is completely wonderful. I love how Shaun makes Donna coffee just like Lance did, minus the Huon particles of course. And the character you made for Shaun fits nicely with the one minute of screen time he got, and their relationship feels so right and evolves so naturally. I think this is what RTD wanted us to get from Donna's ending, but unfortunately he fell a bit short. Thank you so much for filling in the spaces.

And I think you put just enough residual doctor; the night in Hawaii was gripping and a bit painful (but in a good way!) Oh, and the pears. I don't like pears either, and I love that of all the things to leak through... it's the pears.

Lovely job.
Kali: dw :: donna :: yatta_thirty2flavors on February 4th, 2010 01:48 pm (UTC)
I think this is what RTD wanted us to get from Donna's ending, but unfortunately he fell a bit short

Yeah... while I love his character stuff, he does have a tendency to try and cram way too much into a tiny space, and sometimes the unfortuante result is that everything winds up a bit rushed. I can see how, say, more Donna/Shaun did not really have a place in EOT, but the result is definitely something that feels a bit patched together. I dunno. Donna's ending wasn't exactly the one I wanted, but I also don't think it was as completely miserable as some people do.

And I think you put just enough residual doctor;

Hee. It's always, um, incredibly tempting whenever I write post-JE Donna, and while I tried to tone it down in this piece I couldn't quite resist her picking up some sort of Time Lord SOS, lol. And pears! I don't like them either, actually. They're a bit like apples gone wrong.

Thank you!
roses of the day: Donna is Awesomeorelle_peredhil on February 4th, 2010 05:14 am (UTC)
This was absolutely wonderful, though it made me tear up a few times. Oh, Donna. *sniff* I like to think that this is the way things went, with her and Shaun; she must be happy now, surely. And I think that this time she definitely married the right man, who loves her and believes in her more than anything. ♥
Kali: dw :: cloen/rose :: when i'm 64_thirty2flavors on February 4th, 2010 02:04 pm (UTC)
I think she will be happy, yeah. I mean, it's not running around the universe freeing oods, but being happily married and financially secure isn't the worst thing that could happen to a person, especially if they don't know any different. And from what little we saw of Shaun he seemed to care about her, and all Donna really needs is someone with some faith in her.

Thank you!
Rini: [tnc] me luv u long tiem k?starshipawesome on February 4th, 2010 04:12 pm (UTC)
Oh my god. This is godly. I mean really.
This is THE best Donna fic I have ever read.

It’s a weird movie, Donna thinks. She’s certain she liked it more the last time she watched it. Now it just seems wrong.

“Sure,” she says absently, her mind still stuck on flux capacitors.

Love this line! Even though she doesn't remember, a part of her still does; I love seeing her get these echoes of what she once was.

Also, the bit where she says it's like wondering if you've left the stove on, or something - It's very similar to what Joan was saying about John Smith in Human Nature~ which is AWESOME. I was like 'wait does donna find her fob watch? 8D'

But even so, it's marvelous.
Kali: dw :: donna :: wanna bet time boy?_thirty2flavors on February 4th, 2010 04:45 pm (UTC)
Oh, wow, thank you!

Love this line! Even though she doesn't remember, a part of her still does; I love seeing her get these echoes of what she once was.

I am possibly a little in love with the idea of Donna getting echoes, as you put it, or with things lingering. I got really excited in EOT when she bought Wilf that book and didn't know why, lol, it was like RTD was validating all my fanfiction. But yes, I do think stuff would linger -- we saw that in Human Nature/Family of Blood, and again with Agatha Christie.

It's very similar to what Joan was saying about John Smith in Human Nature~ which is AWESOME.

Yes! I was aware of that similarity when I was writing it, though I wasn't sure if it was overt enouhg that anyone would notice. I'm glad you did. Those episodes are some of my very favourites, and I think they hint at what life might be like for Donna now.

Again, thanks for reading! I'm glad you liked it so much.

mortalshufflemortalshuffle on February 5th, 2010 09:37 pm (UTC)
This was beautiful and wonderful and exactly the kind of fic I've been looking for. Lately, I've been put off stuff about Donna because a lot of people are saying Donna's fate is the worst thing imaginable. And yeah, I was in that basket after Journey's End at first. But I started thinking, well, even without her memories she's still Donna Noble. As we saw in Turn Left, no matter what, Donna is Donna. And the fact that she was interested in Shaun in the first place shows that her experiences still affected her in some way even if she doesn't remember, because before the Doctor came into her life she was interested in rich men -- with Shaun, she doesn't care that he's poor. This fic is just so perfectly in character that I felt like I was a fly on the wall. It was so Donna. I just had to break my Doctor Who fanfic lurking status to tell you that.
Kali: dw :: donna :: aren't we all?_thirty2flavors on February 6th, 2010 06:30 pm (UTC)
I do think The Point of Turn Left was to show us that Donna doesn't actually need the Doctor to be awesome, and so I have no trouble believing she can be. All Donna really needs is someone who believes in her and can encourage her, and while that was Ten in s4, there's no reason it can't be Shaun now. And yes, despite the various fandom assertions that she's back to being "stupid" and "shallow" like she was in Runaway Bride, I don't think a pre-Doctor Donna would've been so ready to marry someone making minimum wage.

So thank you! I'm glad you liked it.
Chi: as important as timelordsladychi on February 8th, 2010 04:24 am (UTC)
I'm catching up on all of the fics on my "to-read" list tonight, and this was near the top! I really, really love your characterization of Shaun, and how you've portrayed their relationship. Donna is brilliant, all of the time -- she was brilliant before she knew the Doctor, and after she forgot him, and it was lovely to see her with someone who understands that.

A moving and fantastic piece of work! Thanks for writing it!
Kali: dw :: donna :: plucky young girl_thirty2flavors on February 8th, 2010 09:14 pm (UTC)
Thank you! Yeah, I'm choosing to believe Shaun recognizes Donna's awesome. He seemed like a good guy in the clips we got, and I would hope Donna's taste has improved a bit since Lance. I can understand being sad about Donna never getting her memories back, but I think a lot of the rage over her ending sort of discounts the very real possibility of having a happy life that doesn't involve chasing down aliens.
al: Tardispurple_cube on February 12th, 2010 11:50 am (UTC)
Oh, that's just beautiful. I especially love the penultimate paragraph, with

for some reason the man sitting across the table looks at her like she’s the most important woman in the world. It's not exactly making do, is it?

Because I hope that she really feels like she's not 'making do' and is truly happy. She deserves to be, after all.
Kali: dw :: donna :: what kind of cheap gift?_thirty2flavors on February 12th, 2010 02:20 pm (UTC)
I think Donna will be happy, even if it's not the ending she might have dreamed up for herself. Which I suppose is probably what you could say for all the companions. And of course it's very sad that Donna doesn't get to remember, but... I dunno, she can be awesome on her own.

Thank you!
( 59 comments — Leave a comment )
Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>