I was just in CVS today and I fell in love with these Rimmel eye pencils. I tested out 3 colors and they are great. The pink one comes out more peachy and it compliments my tan PERFECTLY. The teal is great for a thick liner or an all over shadow base. there is also a coppery orange that looks scary but would look pretty with browns or pinks.
I think these cost $5.99 each but look for $1 off coupons in the newspaper.